Delirium ad finem Right now

Did the medicine hasten death?

Many families wonder this, sometimes for years. Here is what the evidence actually shows.

General information, not medical advice. Your care team knows your loved one: ask them.

The short answer

When opioids such as morphine, and sedatives such as midazolam, are used by a palliative team to relieve symptoms, studies have not found that they shorten life. In surveys of high opioid doses in hospice care, the dose was not linked to how long people lived. The research on sedation is less strong, but points the same way. [1–6]

Doses of morphine and sedatives are often higher in the last days, and because doses are given regularly, one is often given shortly before death. Studies have not found that starting or increasing these medicines brings death sooner. The timing feels like cause and effect. The evidence says it usually isn't. [1,4]

"Double effect"

You may hear the phrase double effect. It is an old ethical principle: a treatment given to relieve suffering is acceptable even if it carries a foreseen risk, as long as the intention is relief and the treatment is in proportion to the suffering. [1,4]

It is often quoted about morphine and sedation at the end of life. But the evidence suggests the feared side effect, shortening life, isn't seen when doses are matched to symptoms, so some experts argue the principle is rarely needed at all. [1,4] What matters more is that the dying person was not left in distress.

If you're still carrying this

If you gave a dose the nurse told you to give, and your person died soon after, you did what they needed. The evidence says the medicine almost certainly did not cause their death; the illness did. If it keeps coming back to you, ask the hospice for a talk with the nurse or doctor who was involved, or with their bereavement team. [7–9]

Sources for this page

  1. National Cancer Institute. Last Days of Life (PDQ®), Health Professional Version. Public domain.
  2. National Cancer Institute. Last Days of Life (PDQ®), Patient Version. Public domain.
  3. Marie Curie. End of life medicines. Cited, not copied.
  4. Lancet Oncology (Sykes and Thorns). The use of opioids and sedatives at the end of life. Lancet Oncol 2003;4(5):312-8. Cited, not copied.
  5. Journal of Clinical Oncology (Maltoni et al.). Palliative sedation in end-of-life care and survival: a systematic review. J Clin Oncol 2012;30(12):1378-83. Cited, not copied.
  6. Cochrane (Beller et al.). Palliative pharmacological sedation for terminally ill adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2015, CD010206. Cited, not copied.
  7. U.S. Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 418.204, Hospice: special coverage requirements (continuous care, respite). Public domain.
  8. Medicare (CMS). Medicare Hospice Benefits (publication 02154). Public domain.
  9. NHS. Hospice care. Open Government Licence v3.0.

How we check facts: every medical statement on this site rests on at least two independent sources. More about how this guide is written.